By Indranil Banik

New data on baryon acoustic oscillations strengthen the case for a local cosmic void. The finding offers a possible solution to the Hubble tension.

When we look at the night sky, it can appear as though our cosmic surroundings are filled with countless stars, planets, and galaxies. However, researchers have long proposed that our local region of the universe may contain far fewer galaxies than expected.

Evidence increasingly points to the possibility that we inhabit a vast cosmic void, with a matter density around 20% lower than the cosmic average.

Not every physicist is convinced that this is the case. But our recent paper analyzing distorted sounds from the early universe, published in the Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, strongly backs up the idea.
The Hubble tension problem

Cosmology is currently in a crisis known as the Hubble tension: the local universe appears to be expanding about 10% faster than expected. The expected rate is derived by taking precise observations of the infant universe and projecting them forward using the standard cosmological framework, known as Lambda-Cold Dark Matter (ΛCDM).

We can examine the early universe with exceptional detail through the cosmic microwave background (CMB), the relic radiation dating back to when the universe was about 1,100 times smaller than today. Sound waves that traveled through the hot plasma of the early universe left behind alternating regions of higher and lower density, and thus variations in temperature.

By analyzing fluctuations in the CMB on a range of scales, scientists can effectively “listen” to the echoes of these primordial sound waves, which resonate most strongly at certain characteristic scales.
Baryon acoustic oscillations as a standard ruler

These patterns are preserved in the CMB and are known as baryon acoustic oscillations (BAOs). Because they seeded the formation of galaxies and large-scale structures, the same patterns can also be detected in the present-day distribution of galaxies.

By studying how galaxies cluster at different redshifts (which correspond to distance), researchers can trace these oscillations. One particularly distinctive clustering feature, called the “angular BAO scale,” serves as a key marker.

This feature provides what cosmologists call a “standard ruler,” a known size that allows them to determine distances across the universe. By measuring how large this scale appears in the sky at a given redshift, scientists can calculate both the distance to those galaxies and the rate of cosmic expansion.
Testing the void hypothesis

Using these measurements, cosmologists can determine expansion rates with trigonometry and redshift data. If the BAO feature appears larger at a certain distance, it implies that the local universe is expanding more quickly.

My colleagues and I previously argued that the Hubble tension might be due to our location within a large void. That’s because the sparse amount of matter in the void would be gravitationally attracted to the more dense matter outside it, continuously flowing out of the void.

In previous research, we showed that this flow would make it look like the local universe is expanding about 10% faster than expected. That would solve the Hubble tension.

But we wanted more evidence. And we know a local void would slightly distort the relation between the BAO angular scale and the redshift due to the faster-moving matter in the void and its gravitational effect on light from outside.

So in our new paper, Vasileios Kalaitzidis and I set out to test the predictions of the void model using BAO measurements collected over the last 20 years. We compared our results to models without a void under the same background expansion history.

In the void model, the BAO ruler should look larger on the sky at any given redshift. And this excess should become even larger at low redshift (close distance), in line with the Hubble tension.
Strong evidence for a local void

The observations confirm this prediction. Our results suggest that a universe with a local void is about one hundred million times more likely than a cosmos without one, when using BAO measurements and assuming the universe expanded according to the standard model of cosmology informed by the CMB.

Our research shows that the ΛCDM model without any local void is in “3.8 sigma tension” with the BAO observations. This means the likelihood of a universe without a void fitting these data is equivalent to a fair coin landing heads 13 times in a row. By contrast, the chance of the BAO data looking the way they do in void models is equivalent to a fair coin landing heads just twice in a row. In short, these models fit the data quite well.

In the future, it will be crucial to obtain more accurate BAO measurements at low redshift, where the BAO standard ruler looks larger on the sky – even more so if we are in a void.

The average expansion rate so far follows directly from the age of the universe, which we can estimate from the ages of old stars in the Milky Way. A local void would not affect the age of the universe, but some proposals do affect it. These and other probes will shed more light on the Hubble crisis in cosmology.

Reference: “Testing the local void hypothesis using baryon acoustic oscillation measurements over the last 20 yr” by Indranil Banik and Vasileios Kalaitzidis, 13 May 2025, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society.

Adapted from an article originally published in The Conversation.The Conversation

Photos and more on link:
https://theconversation.com/distorted-sound-of-the-early-universe-suggests-we-are-living-in-a-giant-void-259284