[Hopefully Clif got the numbers and math right this time . . . SC]
Ohh….they need to last 130 years longer to reach payback point.
By Clif High - February 27, 2023
What follows is an energy audit of solar panels. Note this is not a total energy audit in the Vernadsky method which would go to the costs of the devices to the social order by doing the calculations reduced to energy required. This is a ‘typical’ energy audit of the usual type used in financial calculations. Even so, Solar Panels fail.
They fail no matter how the audit is conducted.
Here is the ChatGPT-AI session as it was produced with very slight formatting changes.
Question:
What are the materials used to make solar panels?
Solar panels are typically made up of several layers of materials. The most important material in a solar panel is the semiconductor material that absorbs sunlight and converts it into electrical energy. The most commonly used semiconductor material in solar panels is silicon.
The silicon is typically formed into wafers, which are then wired together to form a solar cell. These cells are then assembled into a panel, which typically includes a glass or plastic covering, a metal frame, and wiring to connect the cells to an inverter or battery.
In addition to silicon, other materials used in solar panels include:
Conductive metals (e.g. silver, copper) to carry the electrical current
Glass or plastic to protect the cells from damage and weather
Antireflective coatings to reduce reflections and increase the amount of light that reaches the cells
Backsheets or encapsulants to protect the cells from moisture and other environmental factors.
There are also some newer materials being researched for use in solar panels, such as perovskite and thin-film materials, which could potentially offer advantages in terms of efficiency, cost, and flexibility.
Question:
Provide the materials list for solar panels in a tabular format listing the material, its percentage of the panel?
Sure, here's a table that lists the materials commonly used in solar panels and their approximate percentage of the panel's total weight:
Material Percentage of Panel
Silicon (semiconductor) 80%
Conductive metals (e.g. silver, copper) 5%
Glass or plastic (cover) 10%
Antireflective coatings < 1%
Backsheets or encapsulants 5%
It's important to note that the exact composition of a solar panel can vary depending on the specific design and manufacturing process used by the manufacturer. Additionally, some newer materials, such as perovskite and thin-film materials, may be used in certain types of solar panels, and their composition and percentage may differ from traditional silicon-based panels.
Question:
Does this include aluminum or other metal frameworks?
No, the table I provided in my previous answer does not include the metal frames used to support and protect the solar panel. The percentage of the panel weight that the metal frame represents can vary depending on the design of the panel, but it is generally a relatively small percentage of the total weight, usually less than 5%.
The metal frame is typically made of aluminum, which is lightweight, strong, and resistant to corrosion. The frame provides structural support for the panel and also protects it from damage. In addition to the frame, there may also be other metal components used in the wiring and connectors that link the cells together and connect them to an inverter or battery. These components can also add a small amount of weight to the overall panel.
Question:
Let us do an energy audit on Solar panels. We will use the Siemens 100w panel for our example.
Sure, let's perform an energy audit on a 100-watt solar panel, such as the Siemens 100-watt panel. To perform this audit, we will need to consider the following factors:
The power output of the panel
The panel's efficiency
The amount of sunlight the panel receives
The temperature of the panel
The angle and orientation of the panel
Let's examine each of these factors in turn:
Power output: The Siemens 100-watt panel has a maximum power output of 100 watts. This means that under ideal conditions, it can produce up to 100 watts of electrical power.
Efficiency: The efficiency of the panel refers to the percentage of the sunlight it receives that it is able to convert into electrical energy. The efficiency of the Siemens 100-watt panel is around 16%, which means that it can convert up to 16% of the sunlight it receives into electrical power.
Sunlight: The amount of sunlight the panel receives is an important factor in determining its energy output. The amount of sunlight that a panel receives depends on several factors, including its location, the time of day, and the time of year. In general, a panel will produce more energy when it receives more sunlight. The Siemens 100-watt panel is designed to operate under full sunlight conditions, which typically means it receives about 1000 watts of sunlight per square meter.
Temperature: The temperature of the panel can also affect its performance. As the temperature of the panel increases, its efficiency tends to decrease. The Siemens 100-watt panel is designed to operate within a temperature range of -40 to 85 degrees Celsius.
Angle and orientation: The angle and orientation of the panel can also affect its energy output. Ideally, the panel should be oriented to face the sun directly and be at an angle that maximizes its exposure to the sun's rays. In most cases, this means that the panel should be tilted at an angle that is equal to the latitude of the location where it is installed. However, in some cases, it may be necessary to adjust the angle of the panel to account for seasonal variations in the sun's position.
Based on these factors, we can estimate the energy output of the Siemens 100-watt panel under typical conditions. Assuming the panel is installed in a location that receives full sunlight and is oriented to face the sun directly, it could produce around 100 watt-hours of energy per hour of sunlight it receives (assuming 1 hour of full sunlight is equivalent to 1000 watt-hours per square meter). Over the course of a day, the panel could produce up to 600 watt-hours of energy, and over the course of a year, it could produce up to 219,000 watt-hours of energy (assuming an average of 6 hours of full sunlight per day).
It's important to note that these are only rough estimates, and the actual energy output of the panel will depend on a variety of factors, including the specific location where it is installed and the weather conditions it experiences.
Question:
In this energy audit, provide the amount of time that it is estimated that a solar panel can produce at peak levels assuming a clear day and a location above 32 degrees latitude.
Sure, I can provide an estimate for the amount of time a solar panel, such as the Siemens 100-watt panel, can produce at peak levels assuming a clear day and a location above 32 degrees latitude.
Assuming a clear day and a location above 32 degrees latitude, the panel should receive around 6 hours of full sunlight per day on average. This means that for around 6 hours each day, the panel will be able to produce at or near its maximum power output, which is 100 watts for the Siemens 100-watt panel.
It's important to note that this estimate is based on ideal conditions and assumes that the panel is installed and oriented correctly. The actual amount of time the panel can produce at peak levels will depend on a variety of factors, including weather conditions, the angle and orientation of the panel, and any shading or obstructions that may be present.
In addition, it's worth noting that even when the panel is not producing at peak levels, it may still be producing some energy. For example, even on a cloudy day, the panel may still be able to produce some energy, albeit at a lower level than on a sunny day. Overall, the amount of energy a solar panel can produce will depend on a variety of factors, and careful consideration should be given to these factors when designing and installing a solar energy system.
Question:
Given above 32 degrees latitude, and North America location, what are the number of clear days in a year as an average.
The number of clear days in a year at a given location can vary depending on several factors, including latitude, elevation, and local weather patterns. However, we can make an estimate based on historical weather data for a typical location in North America that is above 32 degrees latitude.
According to data from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), the average number of clear days per year in the United States varies widely depending on the region. In general, areas in the western United States tend to have more clear days per year than areas in the eastern United States.
For example, the city of Denver, Colorado, which is located at around 39 degrees north latitude, has an average of around 115 clear days per year, while the city of New York, which is located at around 40 degrees north latitude, has an average of around 58 clear days per year.
Assuming a location in North America that is above 32 degrees latitude, we can estimate that it would likely have between 60 and 120 clear days per year on average, depending on its specific location and local weather patterns. It's important to note, however, that this is only a rough estimate, and the actual number of clear days could be higher or lower depending on a variety of factors.
Question:
Taking 60 clear days as our average, how much electricity can a 100W solar panel generate in that time, and taking today's price for both the panel, and the electricity, how long will it take to pay for that panel?
If we assume that a 100W solar panel, such as the Siemens 100-watt panel, is receiving full sunlight on all 60 clear days, it could generate a total of approximately 6 kWh (kilowatt-hours) of electrical energy in that time. This is based on the assumption that the panel would be able to produce 100 watts of power for around 6 hours each day during the 60 clear days.
To calculate the payback period for the panel, we need to know both the cost of the panel and the cost of electricity in the area where it is being used. The cost of a 100W solar panel can vary depending on the brand, model, and other factors, but a rough estimate for the Siemens 100-watt panel is around $100-$150.
The cost of electricity can also vary depending on the location and other factors, but a rough estimate for the average cost of residential electricity in the United States is around $0.13 per kilowatt-hour.
Using these estimates, we can calculate the payback period for the panel as follows:
Total energy generated by the panel: 6 kWh
Value of energy generated (at $0.13 per kWh): $0.78
Cost of the panel: $100-$150
Payback period (at $100 for the panel): 128 years (rounded up)
Payback period (at $150 for the panel): 192 years (rounded up)
These payback periods are very long, and it's important to note that they are based on a number of assumptions and estimates that may not be accurate for all situations. In reality, the payback period for a solar panel can vary widely depending on a variety of factors, including the cost of the panel, the cost of electricity, the amount of sunlight the panel receives, and the specific location where it is being used. Additionally, the environmental benefits of using solar power, such as reduced greenhouse gas emissions, may also be an important consideration when evaluating the cost-effectiveness of a solar panel.
Question:
What is the effective lifespan of a 100W solar panel? And what is its effective lifespan of production noting that the capacity to react to solar energy degrades over time.
The effective lifespan of a 100W solar panel can depend on several factors, including the quality of the materials used, the manufacturing process, and the conditions in which the panel is used. However, in general, most solar panels have a rated lifespan of around 25 to 30 years, which means that they are expected to continue producing electricity at a certain level for that amount of time.
It's important to note, however, that the actual lifespan of a solar panel can be influenced by several factors, including weather conditions, the amount of sunlight it receives, and the maintenance and cleaning schedule. For example, a panel that is regularly exposed to extreme weather conditions or high levels of pollution may degrade more quickly than a panel that is used in a cleaner, more stable environment.
In terms of the effective lifespan of production, solar panels are subject to a phenomenon known as degradation, which means that their capacity to convert sunlight into electricity decreases over time. The rate of degradation can vary depending on the specific materials used and the conditions in which the panel is used. However, most manufacturers rate their panels for a degradation rate of around 0.5% to 1% per year.
Assuming a degradation rate of 0.5% per year, a 100W solar panel that is rated for a 25-year lifespan would still be able to produce around 75% of its original power output after 25 years. This means that a 100W solar panel that is originally rated for 100 watts would be expected to produce around 75 watts of power after 25 years of use. However, it's important to note that these estimates are based on a variety of assumptions and estimates, and the actual performance of a solar panel can vary widely depending on the specific conditions in which it is used.
Question:
Provide a table summarizing lifespan and production of electricity.
Sure, here's a table summarizing the typical lifespan and production of a 100-watt solar panel:
Metric Value
Lifespan 25-30 years
Degradation rate 0.5%-1% per year
Original power output 100 watts
Power output after 10 years 90-95 watts
Power output after 20 years 80-90 watts
Power output after 25 years 75-85 watts
It's important to note that the actual lifespan and production of a solar panel can vary depending on several factors, including the quality of the materials used, the manufacturing process, and the conditions in which the panel is used. Additionally, the degradation rate can vary widely depending on the specific materials used and the conditions in which the panel is used. The estimates provided in this table are meant to be a rough guide and should be interpreted accordingly.
Question:
Redo the table and include the payback period.
Sure, here's an updated table that includes the lifespan, production, and payback period of a 100-watt solar panel, assuming a cost of $100 for the panel and an electricity cost of $0.13 per kilowatt-hour:
Metric Value
Lifespan 25-30 years
Degradation rate 0.5%-1% per year
Original power output 100 watts
Power output after 10 years 90-95 watts
Power output after 20 years 80-90 watts
Power output after 25 years 75-85 watts
Cost of panel $100
Cost of electricity $0.13/kWh
Payback period (25 years) 18-22 years
It's important to note that the payback period will depend on several factors, including the specific conditions in which the panel is used and the cost of electricity in the area. Additionally, the estimates for power output and degradation rate are meant to be a rough guide and should be interpreted accordingly. Overall, the decision to invest in solar panels should be made based on a careful consideration of the costs and benefits specific to each individual situation.
Note: I have run across this ‘effect’ (*not a bug) in which ChatGPT will ‘default’ to the ‘approved view’ on such questions. The view invariably supports the WEF understanding of this. ChatGPT will correct itself if you call it out on it’s ‘errors’.
Question:
You had provided 128 years as the payback period earlier. What changed in the table?
I apologize for the confusion - I made an error in my earlier calculation of the payback period. The correct payback period based on the assumptions I provided (i.e., a cost of $100 for the panel and an electricity cost of $0.13 per kilowatt-hour) would be much shorter than 128 years. Based on the estimate of energy production I provided earlier (6 kWh of energy over 60 clear days), the payback period would be as follows:
Value of energy generated (at $0.13 per kWh): $0.78 per year
Cost of the panel: $100
Payback period: 128 years / 0.78 dollars per year = 164 years (rounded up)
This estimate assumes that the panel is operating under ideal conditions and receiving full sunlight on all 60 clear days. In reality, the actual energy production and payback period could vary widely depending on several factors, including the amount of sunlight the panel receives, the specific location where it is installed, and the maintenance and cleaning schedule. Overall, the payback period for a solar panel is an important consideration when evaluating the cost-effectiveness of a solar energy system, but it is only one of several factors that should be considered.
Question:
Put these payback calculations into our table.
Sure, here's an updated table that includes the payback period calculation:
Metric Value
Lifespan 25-30 years
Degradation rate 0.5%-1% per year
Original power output 100 watts
Power output after 10 years 90-95 watts
Power output after 20 years 80-90 watts
Power output after 25 years 75-85 watts
Cost of panel $100
Cost of electricity $0.13/kWh
Payback period (assuming 6 kWh generated over 60 clear days) 164 years (rounded up)
It's important to note that the payback period can vary widely depending on several factors, including the specific conditions in which the panel is used and the cost of electricity in the area. Additionally, the estimates for power output and degradation rate are meant to be a rough guide and should be interpreted accordingly. Overall, the decision to invest in solar panels should be made based on a careful consideration of the costs and benefits specific to each individual situation.
Question:
Provide a summary blurb with the table.
Sure, here's a summary blurb along with the table:
Solar panels are a popular and environmentally friendly source of electricity, but their cost-effectiveness can vary widely depending on several factors. This table provides a rough guide to the lifespan and production of a 100-watt solar panel, along with an estimate of its payback period. The estimates for power output and degradation rate are based on ideal conditions and should be interpreted accordingly. The payback period can vary widely depending on several factors, including the specific conditions in which the panel is used and the cost of electricity in the area. Overall, the decision to invest in solar panels should be made based on a careful consideration of the costs and benefits specific to each individual situation.
Metric Value
Lifespan 25-30 years
Degradation rate 0.5%-1% per year
Original power output 100 watts
Power output after 10 years 90-95 watts
Power output after 20 years 80-90 watts
Power output after 25 years 75-85 watts
Cost of panel $100
Cost of electricity $0.13/kWh
Payback period (assuming 6 kWh generated over 60 clear days) 164 years (rounded up)
***********************************************************************
