AN EXPLANATION OF THE FACTIONS  
 

[ DONATE TO RMN ] [ View Thread ] [ Archive Search Page ] [ RMN Reading Room ] [ CGI Media News Room ] [ SUBSCRIBE TO RMN ]

RMN is Reader Supported

Our Goal for
APR 6 - MAY 5:
$1,420

Powered by FundRazr

Click Widget
or Click Here to contribute.

Checks & Money Orders:

Raye Allan Smith
P.O. Box 95
Ashtabula, OH 44005


Users Online:
67

Who Founded RMNews?


Dewitt Jones' Video
"Celebrate What's Right
With The World"


"When the
Starships Fly!"

Listen at YouTube


The Theme for The Obergon Chronicles

Listen at YouTube


The Obergon Chronicles ebook


RUMOR MILL
NEWS RADIO


CGI ROOM
Common Ground
Independent Media


WHAT ARE
THE FACTIONS?


THE AMAZING
RAYELAN ALLAN


BIORHYTHMS

LOTTO PICKS

OTHER WAYS TO DONATE





RUMOR MILL NEWS AGENTS WHO'VE BEEN INTERVIEWED ON RUMOR MILL NEWS RADIO

______________

NOVEMBER 2008

Kevin Courtois - Kcbjedi
______________

Dr Robin Falkov

______________

Melinda Pillsbury Hr1

Melinda Pillsbury Hr2

______________

Daneen Peterson

______________

Daneen Peterson

______________

Disclosure Hr1

Disclosure Hr2
______________

Scribe
______________

in_PHI_nitti
______________

Jasmine Hr1
Jasmine Hr2
______________

Tom Chittum Hr1
Tom Chittum Hr2
______________

Kevin Courtois
______________

Dr Syberlux
______________

Gary Larrabee Hr1
Gary Larrabee Hr2
______________

Kevin Courtois
______________

Pravdaseeker Hr1
Pravdaseeker Hr2
______________

DECEMBER 2008

Tom Chittum
______________

Crystal River
______________

Stewart Swerdlow Hr1
Stewart Swerdlow Hr2
______________

Janet Swerdlow Hr1
Janet Swerdlow Hr2
______________

Dr. Robin Falkov Hr1
Dr. Robin Falkov Hr2
Dr. Robin Falkov Hr3

JANUARY 2009 ______________

Patriotlad
______________

Patriotlad
______________

Crystal River
______________

Patriotlad
______________

Dr. Robin Falcov
______________

Patriotlad

FEBRUARY 2009

Find UFOs, The Apocalypse, New World Order, Political Analysis,
Alternative Health, Armageddon, Conspiracies, Prophecies, Spirituality,
Home Schooling, Home Mortgages and more, in:

Rumor Mill News Reading Room, Current Archive

Reader clears up who did most of the composing work on the "Victory at Sea" soundtrack

Posted By: MrFusion
Date: Sunday, 24-Jan-2016 01:08:33
www.rumormill.news/38164

In Response To: A little more Blizzard Music: Richard Rodgers - "The Magnetic North" from the "Victory at Sea" soundtrack (MrFusion)

From reader VAS:
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
The Wikipedia article for "Victory at Sea" will clear up how much/little of the music was actually composed by Richard Rodgers.

For Episode 11, "Magnetic North," the only new thing Rodgers wrote was the simple little tune heard for half a minute around 21:57 (a fiddler and guitarist or two seen onscreen very briefly; Robert Russell Bennett makes it a violin solo in the orchestra).

In "arranging" this episode, Bennett "quotes' bits of Rodgers's opening-credits melody a few times, but--other than that fiddle/guitar tune--RRB composed everything else, including all the "wintry" stuff.

Hope you're getting through the storm OK,

VAS
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

MrF responds:
Yes, after I posted the music I went back and read the Wikipedia article and realized that should post a clarification. But then I decided to wait a little for the inevitable letter from a reader, which indeed came, courtesy reader VAS. My mind had been poisoned by album notes on the Victory at Sea soundtrack albums I listened to as a kid, which heap praise on the 12+ hours of music "composed by Richard Rodgers and arranged by Robert Russell Bennett". I should have been made suspicious by the words "arranged by" which often indicate who did most of the work. It turns out Rodgers' contribution was to sit down at a piano and write 12 short catchy "themes" to be incorporated into the soundtrack, but it was Bennett who did the creative heavy lifting of composing the 12-13 hours of orchestral music, blending Rodgers recognizable themes here and there into Bennett's own original music. To be fair, writing short, catchy themes was something Rodgers was really good at, and the basis of his reputation. If you buy the soundtrack, or the whole series on DVD, you will be able to pick out his show-tune-like themes here and there and say, oh, that's one of Rodgers'. But to give him the primary composing credit was clearly unwarranted.



RMN is an RA production.

Articles In This Thread

A little Blizzard Music as we wait for the snow to stop: R. Vaughan Williams: Prelude from "Sinfonia Antarctica" (Sym.#7)
MrFusion -- Saturday, 23-Jan-2016 16:32:52
A little more Blizzard Music: Richard Rodgers - "The Magnetic North" from the "Victory at Sea" soundtrack
MrFusion -- Saturday, 23-Jan-2016 17:35:05
Reader clears up who did most of the composing work on the "Victory at Sea" soundtrack
MrFusion -- Sunday, 24-Jan-2016 01:08:33

The only pay your RMN moderators receive
comes from ads.
If you're using an ad blocker, please consider putting RMN in
your ad blocker's whitelist.


Serving Truth and Freedom
Worldwide since 1996
 
Politically Incorrect News
Stranger than Fiction
Usually True!


Powered
by FundRazr
Click Widget
or Click Here to contribute.


Organic Sulfur 4 Health

^


AGENTS WEBPAGES

Provided free to RMN Agents

Organic Sulfur 4 Health

^


AGENTS WEBPAGES

Provided free to RMN Agents



[ DONATE TO RMN ] [ View Thread ] [ Archive Search Page ] [ RMN Reading Room ] [ CGI Media News Room ] [ SUBSCRIBE TO RMN ]

Rumor Mill News Reading Room, Current Archive is maintained by Forum Admin with WebBBS 5.12.

If you can't find what you're looking
for using our RMN search, try the DuckDuckGo search below:


AN EXPLANATION OF THE FACTIONS