: From CGI member Christ:

**************************************

National Socialism Daydream
1900s

Morgan, I don't want to offend you with this post, just resonating on the Heading. The more I read this Alfred Rosenberg book, Myth of the 20th Century, which forms the pinions of the Nazi Party, the more I think the rise of Nazism and the Advent of World War Two are improbable except in some war-driven God looking for an excuse to get it on.

VICTORY

The Germans got their ass kicked in WW1. Why would they think it would turn out differently a second time, going against the same countries including Russia, United States.

ARIANISM

A citizen ascribing to GERMAN PURITY would be loath to relate to an old FOREIGN SYMBOL from Asia, called a Swastika. The argument that Germany is related to 3000 year old Ancient Indian Culture is for Scholastics only. I'm not sure if a Citizenry would actually fight to the death for the concept. Its a long journey from Indian Dark Masters to Nordic Blond ones.

Were there any significant number of Indians or Pakistani's that lived in Germany during post War 1920s? I thought South Asians identified themselves more with their English Colonizers, (not the English Nordic-Arian ancestors, the VIKINGS or DANES).

GERMAN PURE CULTURE

The artistic and philosophic heroes which Hitler wanted us to relate to, are thought of as second rate or hundereds of years out of date. Goethe, Kant, or Mozart, Beethoven, Handel. How could a 1920s kid get excited about them, as opposed to international contemporary Art, Culture, Music, Radio, Movies.

THE JEWS

Kicking the Jews out (by a group of 'state gangsters'), does not qualify the Germans as a stronger fighting force internationally. Confiscated property cannot really be used directly in an international fight.

THE STRATEGY

The Germans needed 1 of 3 things to make this an Internationally successful undertaking. Alone, their population was 1/4 of their enemies, excluding the United States. They were going to lose by the numbers regardless.

The three possible strategies

1. UNITING NORDIC TYPES

Though it is claimed all European countries have Nordic Western Roots, these countries did not identify with Racial Ideology, to the extent it would unite a Revolution.

2. FIGHTING COMMUNISTS

By 1937, the fight against Communism was essentially over. Western Countries were not threatened by internal 'Communist Takeovers', they had been contained, probably by 1920 and were content to implement Socialist Platforms (healthcare, old age care, unemployment insurance). A Pan-Anti Communist Reformation was some God's Imaginary Propagandist Tool.

3. ANTI SEMITISM

The world had assimilated the Jews by the 1900, Other European Countries did not see the Jews as the dire threat to their livelihoods, the Germans warranted them to be.
You couldn't undertake a World-Wide Ethnic Cleansing on that single issue. Also, there were too many other non-Nordic Ethnic types in the world which would have resisted persecution of any ethnics.

UNDERAGE NATION

With Germany reeling from population decimation at the end of WW 1, it is an impossibility to 'grow' the same quality and numbers of an Imperial Germany fighting force raised in a ravaged, looted country featuring Poverty, Despair, No Parents. These 1920s kids would have been about 14 years old at the start of the War. They aren't ready for Prime-Time.

HINDENBURG

The German Reparations Payments to the Allies came to an end by 1932, before Hitler's rise. Why would Germany feel the need to make war on these countries after?

CHRIST