Predictably, you repeat your lies in ever greater detail, with the idea that if you say it enough times, people will believe it. This is precisely the "Big Lie" technique, enunciated clearly by Adolph Hitler in "Mein Kampf".

I do not know what sort of Judaism Israel Shahak was taught as a child, but I know what I was taught: that all men (and women) are equally the children of God, and that all are "created equal". The Ten Commandments state that "the stranger within thy gates" is to be accorded the same legal protection and the same human respect as the Jew.

The tribal exclusionism that you allege to be inherent in Judaism is utterly alien to the Judaism that I know. It sounds like something Mark Seely would support, but that is another matter. I don't know what Mr. Seely's religious affiliations are, but he has posted here his belief that it is "unnatural" for people to care about those not of their tribe. I couldn't disagree more.

Finally, let me just confirm that Mark Levy's argument with you is quite separate from mine. The only thing they have in common is the fact that you (Jana) are a liar.